Getting to Know Your Code of Best Practices

Peter Jaszi
July 13, 2008

The July 7 release of the new “Code of Best Practices in Fair Use for Online Video” (coordinated by the Center for Social Media and PIJIP) has given rise to an important question about how to interpret the document’s six “Principles” and their associated “Limitations.” So it may be worth noting that all the principles also are subject to some general limiting considerations. One of these is what might be called a “rule of proportionality.” At the top of p. 4 of the document, users are encouraged always to ask: “Was the material taken appropriate in kind and amount, considering the nature of the copyrighted work and the use”? Even when proportionality isn’t mentioned as a specific “Limitation” on a given “Principle,” it is an important touchstone. Take, for example, the fifth principle, concerning “Copyright, Reposting, and Recirculating a Work or Part of a Work for Purposes of Launching a Discussion.” The Code says that such uses are fair when “content that originally was offered to entertain or inform or instruct is offered up for the distinct purposes of launching an on-line discussion” so long as the discourse-promoting intent of the person who does the offering is both subjectively sincere and objectively clear. It does not say, in so many words, that the amount of material used should be proportional to the purpose, but that qualification is implied. Thus, for example, the Code would support posting a brief relevant clip from a recent feature film to start a discussion on the implicit racism in the depiction of screen villains, but it could not be used to justify putting up the film in its entirety. Of course, application of the rule of proportionality depends on the length of the work involved. The Code would support posting an entire 30-second public service announcement to kick off a stream of comments on government policies on the promotion of sexual abstinence.

Permalink : Comments (5) :

Reader Comments

The "Code of Best Practices in Fair Use for Online Video" is a great handbook for those who do not have experience in correctly citing and using work in videos.
Michael Pillsbury on 07-Aug-09 04:47 PM

I think the rule of proportionality is one of the most important principles when working in this field.
Randall Slagle on 11-Aug-09 09:54 PM

It's too often that work is not cited correctly. Thankfully, corporations don't target students for copyright infringement. Still, students should learn to cite correctly at a young age.
Michael Melen on 12-Aug-09 12:18 AM

I remember that I never used correct copyright standards and never paid attention to it when I was a student in college. However, my publisher gave me a lot of trouble about it when I got my first job. It's good to learn early so this is a great handbook.
Toko Obat on 12-Aug-09 12:19 AM

These videos are really effective for learning. Visual learning always benefits rather than old system of learning. Thanks for sharing this "getting to know your code of best practices" http://www.easymud.com http://www.datelot.com http://www.ekjodi.com
d.leon33 on 21-Sep-09 02:06 AM

Online videos are good learning tool but there should not be abused in any way such as plagiarism and other abuse on copyright issues. The codes you provided here are helpful
cargo liner on 10-Nov-09 03:42 AM

online video are very good, there are swineflu in our country now, because of quarantine all institute are close till 22 of november. So we decided to use online lessons. I must say this is the best way in our situation.
writing services on 10-Nov-09 10:32 AM

<a href="http://www.nettopshopping.com/ugg-boots-c-55.html">uggs on sale</a> Sand Paisley Classic Short for Women.With the beautifull shape,stable quality and the attractive design,it won warm praise from customers,selling well all over the world.Special Sale Offering,Real Brand New,Authentic Quality and Package,Free Shipping and Customs,1 Week Delivery To Your Door!Don't miss this good opportunity. Reasonable price,the price is including shipping cost.Many other styles in stock.This style tends to run a size large. Discounted UGG Sundance Boots We recommend ordering a size smaller from your typical shoe size. If you are in-between sizes, we recommend ordering a half down. These Women's <a href="http://www.nettopshopping.com/ugg-boots-ugg-classic-short-c-55_48.html">UGG classic short</a> Boots are comfortable, too, fitting as snugly as a second skin. And because they are comfortable, people are wearing them everywhere with everything. The styles of <a href="http://www.nettopshopping.com/ugg-boots-c-55.html">ugg boots</a> range from tall to short and everywhere in between. There are clog styles and slipper styles
Jane on 10-Nov-09 09:37 PM

I agree with the issues. We need to follow the standards if the better development in procedures is going to be reached. Ric D., http://www.supplements365.com
Sports supplements on 10-Nov-09 11:15 PM

The availability of codes of best practices will at least give us guides about what is good and bad. Thank you. http://www.uniontelecard.com/
international calling cards on 11-Nov-09 12:12 AM

It's great that this code of practice exists. It's very important that all video posters and users of copyrighted material cite their sources and are not in breach of copyright law.
Video Production on 11-Nov-09 07:08 AM

http://www.uggsmvp.com
ugg boots sale on 12-Nov-09 01:25 AM

If Internet users are just more controllable, it should be useful to post such codes of best practices like this. Thank you. Mary, http://www.allwebservices.co.uk/
Web Design Company on 12-Nov-09 09:26 AM

I am thankful for such a great post with many new things to learn. Thanks, you cleared up some things for me.Just what I was googling for! Thanks for sharing! http://dwimarni.com http://newreil.com http://cellphoneleash.net
Kenali dan Kunjungi Objek Wisata di Pandeglang on 12-Nov-09 01:11 PM

Video is becoming an essential part of the online Real Estate world. For this reason I am investing a lot of time in learning best practices as well as learning the legal side of what I can and cannot do with it. This is very helpful to me. Thanks!!
Auburn Real Estate on 12-Nov-09 05:38 PM

Yes, and video marketing will soon boom in demand in the online advertising industry. We just need to prepare for the trend. Best Regards, Jim from http://businessadvertising4free.com
Business Advertising for Free on 12-Nov-09 08:33 PM

I like the idea behind the development of such codes. But what is much more important is the implementation. http://www.buyautoparts.com
Discount auto parts on 12-Nov-09 11:34 PM

Thank you. I need this information to comprehend my on-progress report. The use of online video has been more impressed nowadays. Jalice, http://www.jobtrio.com
construction industry on 13-Nov-09 05:55 AM

I agree with the issues. We need to follow the standards if the better development in procedures is going to be reached.
wholesale automotive products on 13-Nov-09 07:15 AM

You will like the air jordan shoes,you will found the shoes make you become more and more beautiful.
air jordan shoes on 14-Nov-09 02:06 AM

Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.
Seo and Tehnology on 14-Nov-09 06:13 PM

Thank you. I also think that it is important to matter code of best practices. Even though most rules can be kept unwritten, sometimes we need more as a universal rule. http://www.sextoys365.com.au/
sex shop on 15-Nov-09 01:40 AM

I agree with the code of best practices. Even though no one can supervise what video uploaders do with their responsibility, at least they should know about this. http://www.compass-direct.com/newparentlist.html
New Parent List on 15-Nov-09 04:03 AM

Online videos are good learning tool but there should not be abused in any way such as plagiarism and other abuse on copyright issues.
discount outdoor lights on 15-Nov-09 09:07 AM

Maybe it is will not useful to publish codes like this when people are still that ignoring. But we're all hoping for the best.. http://www.thehorseexchange.com
Horse Sales on 15-Nov-09 08:48 PM

Thank you for this article, Kind regards, Lockerz Invites.
Lockerz Invites on 15-Nov-09 09:44 PM

I hope this code of best practices will help for a standard format of uploading video. They should also matter the copyright and originality. Good luck! David, http://www.discountsafes.co.uk
Fire safes on 15-Nov-09 11:01 PM

Hi an thank you for that round up. I like to get more information about code and video best pratice! http://www.vianos.de/suchmaschinenoptimierung.html
webdesign nürnberg on 16-Nov-09 07:23 AM

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you! Thank you for your info.i love to read all info.
thailand travel on 16-Nov-09 12:02 PM

I like the idea behind the development of such codes.I agree with the code of best practices. Even though no one can supervise
shopping online on 16-Nov-09 12:07 PM

Online videos are good learning tool but there should not be abused in any way such as plagiarism and other abuse on copyright issues.
auto insurance on 16-Nov-09 12:31 PM

Online videos are good learning tool but there should not be abused in any way such as plagiarism and other abuse on copyright issues. The codes you provided here are helpful
auto insurance on 16-Nov-09 12:32 PM

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
ps3 repair guide on 16-Nov-09 07:40 PM

Really a educative and informative post, the post is good in all regards,I am glad to read this post
Muscle Might on 17-Nov-09 01:27 AM

Learning via online videos is much interesting, and in any ways can be efficient. But, copyright is not to be forgotten, so this guide is truly needed.
Baby Slings on 17-Nov-09 04:05 AM

Every new release of Code of Best Practices is always useful to improve the way people act. there should be set rules, no matter how liberal your life is. Thanks! http://www.spiritjourneys.com
Gay Travel on 17-Nov-09 06:21 AM

Thank you very much for the information provided! I was looking for this data for a long time, bit I was not able to find the trusted source
Essay Writing Service on 18-Nov-09 06:46 AM

there should be set rules, no matter how liberal your life is
Buy kamagra on 18-Nov-09 10:41 AM

Thank you for your info.
Essay Service on 18-Nov-09 10:43 AM

very interesting approach Angel from http://www.freshbedroom.com
mattress bedroom furniture on 18-Nov-09 02:59 PM

very cool site site! I am loving it!! Will come back again - taking you feeds also, Thanks.
Oes Tsetnoc on 18-Nov-09 03:03 PM

Secret Admirer on 20-Nov-09 09:28 PM

Search PIJIP

Getting to Know Your Code of Best Practices

Reader Comments